Skip to content

Regardless of scandals, key California politicians glide towards reelection. This is why.


A California insurance coverage commissioner who billed taxpayers for long-distance residing bills and broke a vow to not settle for marketing campaign donations from members of the trade he was elected to control.

A state treasurer sued for sexual harassment and wrongful termination and criticized for a way a lot she charged taxpayers for enterprise journeys.

A superintendent of public instruction accused of making a poisonous office and flouting state guidelines by hiring a buddy from out of state to a top-paying place on the California Division of Schooling.

Three of California’s eight statewide constitutional officers up for reelection in November — all Democrats — have had missteps or confronted allegations of misconduct throughout their first 4 years in workplace, however voters do not appear to thoughts.

June’s major election outcomes present that each one three are prone to cruise to reelection — a phenomenon that political analysts chalk as much as the facility of incumbency, California’s polarized politics and voter apathy towards lesser-known places of work.

Both voters aren’t paying consideration or have determined that the incumbents are nonetheless their best choice, even in unhealthy occasions, stated Jessica Levinson, an ethics skilled and professor at Loyola Legislation College.

“I believe there are some individuals who will say, ‘Do I need a Democrat who would possibly do a questionable job or do I need a Republican who holds views which are anathema to mine?’” Levinson stated. “That isn’t a terrific place to be once we’re speaking about actually vital positions.”

Other than the governor and presumably the state lawyer basic, California’s statewide officers usually face sleeper races and little opposition even when an incumbent is singed by scandal. That is regardless of these officeholders being in command of quite a lot of state businesses that have an effect on the lives of voters, from their pensions to the roads they drive on and the faculties their youngsters attend.

Practically 47% of registered voters in California are Democrats, 24% are Republican and near 23% are “no social gathering choice.” A Republican has not been elected statewide in California since 2006.

That might be a part of the issue in the case of voter disengagement, stated Invoice Lockyer, a Democrat who served as each state treasurer and lawyer basic below former Govs. Grey Davis and Arnold Schwarzenegger.

“A few of it could simply be the comparatively noncompetitive political surroundings proper now in our state. The Democrats have it so outnumbered that nobody on the Republican aspect can finance opposition spending that may possibly make these points extra speedy to voters,” stated Lockyer, who additionally served as president professional tem of the the state Senate within the Nineties. “We all know that an knowledgeable and voters is important to make it work, and it is actually disappointing when you do not have it.”

Eric Schickler, a UC Berkeley political science professor and co-director of the college’s Institute of Governmental Research, stated the identical political dynamic has performed out for one more statewide constitutional officer: Gov. Gavin Newson.

Schickler pointed to Newsom’s simple defeat of a recall try final yr and his anticipated reelection in November as proof of an period of “pervasive polarization” over cultural points that has made it simple for Democrats in California to cruise to a second time period. Regardless of snafus like his dinner on the tony French Laundry restaurant within the Napa Valley through the COVID-19 lockdown, voters final yr overwhelmingly determined to maintain Newsom in workplace.

“As soon as it turned a actuality… then voters are fascinated about, ‘OK, there’s Newsom, however what is the different?’” Shickler stated of the recall.

One among Sacramento’s most up-to-date political scandals got here in 2019, when incumbent Insurance coverage Commissioner Ricardo Lara issued an apology after a San Diego Union-Tribune investigation discovered that he violated a marketing campaign promise and accepted tens of 1000’s of {dollars} in donations from insurance coverage executives, many with enterprise earlier than his division.

Controversy continued for Lara — a former state lawmaker — when he confronted criticism for utilizing taxpayer cash to pay hire on a Sacramento condominium whereas he maintained his principal tackle in Los Angeles.

The insurance coverage commissioner is now on the middle of a Honest Political Practices Fee investigation right into a grievance that alleges political committees funneled marketing campaign funds from trade members to help in his reelection.

Nonetheless, Lara received 35.9% of the June 7 major election vote, in comparison with the 18.1% his Republican opponent obtained. Lara did face a formidable Democratic challenger within the major: Assemblymember Marc Levine of Greenbrae, who narrowly misplaced advancing to the November poll after operating a marketing campaign that blasted Lara and promised “new management” within the division.

Robin Swanson, spokesperson for Lara’s reelection marketing campaign, stated voters are unfazed by the political drama so long as elected officers do their jobs.

She pointed to Lara’s work to offer monetary safety to wildfire victims who’ve misplaced their properties and to higher put together communities for local weather change-related disasters like floods and warmth waves.

“I see this as only a rejection of political mudslinging,” Swanson stated. Voters tune it out. They’d relatively hear what candidates are doing for them.”

One other Democrat, State Treasurer Fiona Ma, is equally well-positioned earlier than the November election. Ma earned 57.4% of the vote in June and can face a Republican who obtained simply 21.9% of ballots solid.

However throughout her tenure as California’s banker, Ma, a future gubernatorial prospect, was sued for harassment and wrongful termination by a employee who additionally alleged racial and incapacity discrimination.

Ma additionally confronted criticism for charging taxpayers greater than $32,000 in lodging and meal bills to journey repeatedly from her house in San Francisco to Sacramento, a observe that different statewide officers don’t have interaction in, a Sacramento Bee investigation discovered.

Ma has rejected accusations of misconduct and referred to as ongoing litigation “frivolous” and the results of a “disgruntled worker” who was terminated for efficiency points. She stated she now commutes to and from her house de ella in San Francisco every day.

Ma stated she desires voters to deal with initiatives she oversees as state treasurer to extend reasonably priced housing tasks in California and ease burdens to homeownership for low- and middle-income residents. She touted a brand new program to arrange school financial savings accounts for low-income youngsters in California and plans to make use of social media to get extra youth concerned in recycling efforts.

“I’ve accomplished about 300 Zoom webinars simply within the pandemic, to small enterprise house owners, nonprofits, spiritual organizations, seniors, veterans, getting out the phrase about all the totally different assets on the federal, state, native and personal sectors. That is one thing I am very pleased with,” Ma stated.

Supt. of Public Instruction Tony Thurmond, a Democrat overseeing a nonpartisan workplace, earned 45.9% of the vote in June, whereas his Republican challenger received 11.9%.

Thurmond has confronted complaints from workers who alleged he’s a hostile boss, which has resulted in excessive turnover in top-level Division of Schooling positions. At the least two of his workers resigned after the state questioned his means to rent folks residing out of state for jobs bankrolled by California taxpayers. He has additionally confronted criticism for his dealing with of college closures and distance studying through the pandemic.

Thurmond has stated he has had “powerful conversations with myself” about these points and that “my job as a pacesetter is to take powerful suggestions on a regular basis.” He stated he’s focusing his reelection marketing campaign on scholar psychological well being, literacy and mending tutorial fallout from COVID-19.

Lance Christensen, who works for the conservative California Coverage Middle, and is operating towards Thurmond for superintendent, stated he’s floored by how shortly the current controversies appear to evaporate with out penalties.

Christensen, a Republican, blames each the state’s Democratic super-majority and a ignorance about what energy the positions really maintain, which has led to voter apathy, he stated.

“There isn’t any accountability with the Democrats in Sacramento,” he stated. “I am simply hoping that folks pays extra consideration to the leaders who’re ostensibly alleged to be main our state, and actually, aren’t.”

California’s different statewide officer holders — together with Newsom, Lt. Gov. Eleni Kounalakis, Atty. Gen. Rob Bonta and Secretary of State Shirley Weber, all Democrats — are additionally up for reelection.

Voters may also be offered with two new faces within the state controller race, the place Republican Lanhee Chen is vying towards Democrat Malia Cohen.

Present state Controller Betty Yee is terming out. Yee, too, stepped into controversy earlier this yr when it was revealed she helped dealer a failed COVID-19 pandemic masks deal that value California $600 million.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *